The Crewneck Sweatshirt Really Is a Wardrobe Essential

The Crewneck Sweatshirt Really Is a Wardrobe Essential

The best crewneck sweatshirts for men prove the naysayers wrong. Right now, the phrase “wardrobe essential” is almost as overused as “streetwear” in the menswear universe, but there’s still one style that deserves the label: the gray crewneck sweatshirt. It’s basic in the best way—cozy as a camp fire on the beach, never not wearable, and an integral part of menswear (not to mention cinematic) history.

The humble gray crewneck sweatshirt helped Steve McQueen evade capture in The Great Escape, cemented John Travolta’s heartthrob status in Grease, and made Eddie Murphy a badass in Beverly Hills Cop. Paul Newman, the patron saint of laid-back menswear, wore one religiously. And today, a roster of famous—and famously stylish—dudes still put their trust in it.

The allure is equal parts form and function, a distinct mix of hard-earned ruggedness wrapped in the blanketed exterior of a fine cotton knit. (Think of it as a perfect menswear baguette: hard on the outside and soft as a cloud within.) But the style’s enduring popularity also means the market is flooded with spins on the athletic-inspired classic, and finding the right one can feel like more hassle than it’s worth. So to help you chase a menswear icon status of your own we hunted down all the highest-quality, supremely versatile, absolute best crewneck sweatshirts for men available today. [Insert endlessly quotable movie line here.]

The Best All-Around Crewneck Sweatshirt

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sleeve, Long Sleeve, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Todd Snyder + Champion midweight pocket sweatshirt

Chief among Todd Snyder’s talents is that he knows how garments should fit—and fit well—on actual humans, not stick-thin male models named Sven. This sweatshirt hugs in the right places (biceps, back) and is relaxed where you want it to be (neck, belly). Snyder also isn’t the type to phone it in if he’s designing the best version of an iconic piece of menswear. Every detail on this crewneck, from the wider cuffs to the thicker waistband hem to the chest pocket to the “V” stitch under the collar to the raglan sleeve (the kind that’s attached on an angle to the neck rather than the shoulder) is culled from the kinds of standard-issue sweats guys wore in gymnasiums and on the weekend 50-plus years ago, just reimagined the right way for today’s tastes. Like most of our favorite sweatshirts, it’s crafted from a cotton-and-polyester blend (in this case 80/20) that provides the right mix of structure and softness (as nice to the touch on the outside as it spongy on the inside). All of that—coupled with a perfect shade of heather gray—makes for a sweatshirt that looks good in every situation imaginable, whether you’re hanging out in jeans and Chucks on the weekend or pairing it with an Oxford and tweed blazer at the office.

The Best Affordable Crewneck Sweatshirt

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, Sweatshirt, Human, and Person

Russell Athletic Dri-Power fleece sweatshirt

If your sweatshirt budget is decidedly smaller, your first stop should be Russell Athletic, the Alabama sportswear stalwarts who literally invented the crewneck sweatshirt way back in 1926. Almost a century later, they’re still turning out the best bang-for-your-buck option on the market—classically cut (size down if big and boxy isn’t your vibe) from beefy fleece for approximately $20 a pop.

The Best Painstakingly Authentic Crewneck Sweatshirt

The Real McCoy’s U.S. Navy sweatshirt

Even by Japanese standards, The Real McCoy’s obsession with vintage Americana feels singular and strange. Since the early aughts, the tiny Kobe label has become legendary in menswear circles for its meticulous reproductions of early 20th-century icons: A-2 leather bomber jacket handcrafted from real-deal horsehide; selvedge jeans chain-stitched exactly the way Levi’s were in the 1940s; herringbone chore coats that look like they came straight off the rack of an Old West general store. Their sweatshirts are, unsurprisngly, just as painstakingly constructed—the fabric is spun on loopwheel machines from the ’20s, and then all sewn together on vintage sewing machines. If you really want to feel like one of the midcentury style heroes we mentioned up top—your McQueens and Newmans and the like—then this is the way to go.

The Best (Un)Necessarily Opulent Crewneck Sweatshirt

Mr P. circular knit cashmere sweatshirt

Should you want to graduate from the usual big-box mall brand fare, there are plenty of bougier crewneck sweatshirts out there, too. (Keep scrolling and you’ll see.) And if the thought of a cotton or poly-blend sweatshirt is still irking you but a conventional cashmere sweater seems too dressy, rest assured, there’s a magical sweet spot in-between. Mr Porter’s not-so-humble take on the style, made out of pure primo cashmere, looks just like the usual gym-class sweatshirts you’re used to but ups the luxe ante considerably. You could potentially wear it over a crisp button-up, of course. But consider this lounge-ready joint your official new “nice sweatshirt”.

The Best Bonfire-Ready Crewneck Sweatshirt

Outerknown “Sur” sweatshirt

Outerknown, the sustainably-minded California imprint founded by pro surf legend Kelly Slater, specializes in easy-wearing Angeleno staples that won’t make you look like a beach bum. (Or, for that matter, the beach bum.) Naturally, the brand’s best-selling sweatshirt is cut from a supremely cozy French terry fabric crafted from a blend of slubby hemp and plush, good-for-the-planet organic cotton. The Sur comes in over half a dozen sun-dappled colors, but the heather gray version you’re looking at here is the most versatile by a mile. Sure, you could throw it on with board shorts to keep cozy before an early-morning surf sesh, but it’s sharp enough to pull double-duty at the office when you swap the trunks for chinos, too. You know that warm and fuzzy feeling you get watching the sun set over the water after a long day in the sun? Pulling this guy over your head is like wrapping yourself in that feeling year-round, no beach necessary.

25 More Crewneck Sweatshirts We Love

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sleeve, Long Sleeve, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Fear of God Essentials logo-flocked cotton-blend sweatshirt

Jerry Lorenzo—the man reinventing luxury American fashion—knows how to cut rakishly relaxed clothing better than almost any designer on the planet. So, yes, this sweatshirt is cozy as hell—but it’s plenty stylish too.

Uniqlo long-sleeve sweatshirt

Fluffy, soft, and way more affordable than it should be.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

J.Crew heritage 14 oz. fleece sweatshirt

If you needed more proof of J.Crew’s comeback, just peep the old-school looks of this beaut.

John Elliott oversized crewneck sweatshirt

Because the guy who made gussied-up sweats a bona fide thing ain’t slowing down any time soon.

Image may contain: Sweater, Clothing, Apparel, Sweatshirt, Human, and Person

Champion Life reverse weave sweatshirt

Even minus Todd Snyder’s discerning eye, Champion makes a damn good sweatshirt.

Image may contain: Sweater, Clothing, Apparel, Sleeve, Long Sleeve, Sweatshirt, Human, and Person

Reigning Champ mid weight terry sweatshirt

The best hoodie on the market remains all kinds of excellent without the hood.
Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Carhartt WIP “Chase” sweatshirt

Every bit as hardy as you hoped from the first name in workwear.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, Sweatshirt, Human, Person, Sleeve, and Long Sleeve

Goodlife Clothing terry crew sweatshirt

Okay, we lied: not every killer crewneck sweatshirt has to come in gray. Goodlife’s all-black number is done up in an ultra-soft brushed terry and—shameless plug alert—it’s the star of our latest Box. Subscribe today and you can snag it (along with a whole host of luxe fall-ready upgrades) for a mere 50 bucks.

L.L.Bean classic crewneck sweatshirt

Oh-so-soft, oh-so-substantial.

Brunello Cucinelli cotton sweatshirt

The Italian fabric maestro known for his decadently soft cashmere also makes a killer cotton crewneck.

Studio D’Arstisan loopwheeled crewneck sweatshirt

The Japanese-made loopwheeled joint you might not need, but definitely deserve.

Thom Browne four bar-stripe ribbed sweatshirt

Your ticket to the cool kids’ table is but a click away.
Image may contain: Clothing, Sleeve, Apparel, Long Sleeve, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Sunspel loopback sweatshirt

There’s a reason Daniel Craig’s Bond swore by Sunspel’s sturdy basics: the heritage British label has been in the business for a long time, and its elegant take on classic-leaning sportswear is as good as it gets.

Andersson Bell paneled sweatshirt

Paneled perfection.

Handvaerk pima cotton sweatshirt

Cut from a cotton-jersey fabric so soft your favorite hoodie just shuddered.

Lady White Co. relaxed sweatshirt

It’s no secret we’re big fans of LWC’s pitch-perfect tees. Also great? The L.A. label’s supremely slouchy sweats.
Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Warehouse reverse weave loopwheel sweatshirt

Short of scouring the racks at your local, ah, curated vintage spot, you’d be hard-pressed to find a more authentic riff on the source material than this.

Ghiaia cashmere raglan crewneck sweatshirt

Ghiaia’s wildly luxurious cashmere sweats are made in Italy, but their spirit skews more laid-back Angenelo than high-strung import/export magnate.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, Sweatshirt, Sleeve, Long Sleeve, Human, and Person

Les Tien heavyweight crop sweatshirt

Dense, soft, and cut in an ultra-flattering cropped fit. What else would you expect from a brand started by a former Kanye West consigliere?

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Buck Mason Interloop crew sweatshirt

The yarn-dyed French terry means that this heathered fabric is really heathering.

Image may contain: Clothing, Sleeve, Apparel, and Long Sleeve

Everlane track crewneck sweatshirt

If the regular fit and the broken-in French terry fabric weren’t enough to convince you, the feel-good organic cotton will.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, Sweatshirt, Sleeve, Long Sleeve, Human, and Person

ASKET melange sweatshirt

Asket’s expanded range of sizing includes short and tall lengths, giving you the next closest thing to a custom-tailored sweatshirt.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Alex Mill garment dyed crewneck sweatshirt

Alex Mill’s sweatshirt is like a hit song you can’t stop bumping on repeat. Add it your closet and then keep it the mix all year long.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Human, Person, and Pajamas

Nike Sportswear club fleece crewneck sweatshirt

Just buy it.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

RRL fleece crewneck sweatshirt

As with all things classically American, Ralph absolutely nails the crewneck sweatshirt.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sweater, Sweatshirt, Sleeve, and Long Sleeve

3sixteen heavyweight crewneck sweatshirt

It’s the pockets for us.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, and Undershirt

Mott & Bow French terry sweatshirt

A simple-looking sweatshirt—with no contrast stitching at the neck or sleeves, if that’s not your thing—executed in a just-right medium weight cotton.

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Sleeve, Long Sleeve, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Hanes Ecosmart fleece sweatshirt

Tough to beat a bare bones basic at a bare bones price.