When September rolls around every year, I am in denial about saying goodbye to summer without fail. I usually refuse to wear jeans, pants, tights, and other leg-covering materials until I find myself shivering away. And I sparingly wear boots, flats, and closed-toe shoes, trying to get the most out of what’s left of sandal season. So yeah, you can say I have a hard time letting go of things.

But because I am still pushing the limits of my sandal wearing until October, I have one concession for fall: I like to choose autumn-inspired hues for my pedicures. You know, the dark, moody, sexy colors of cooler months. And hey, even if you’ve been wearing boots, you don’t have to feel left out. You can still treat those toes of yours to a fall pedi. Make it a part of your self-care routine.

Whether you’re all in with fall or are having trouble like me, I’ve gathered some of the best fall pedicure color ideas and nail polishes to get the look.